Default Featured image

False Information on the URLA Really Matters

Creditor-Side Bankruptcy and Real Estate Law by Peter N. Brewer, Esq.

In the days before the financial crisis, it was common that borrowers or their loan brokers would intentionally falsify information on the Uniform Residential Loan Application (URLA) to qualify for a loan.  This was especially true with so many lenders offering Stated Income and Stated Asset (SISA) loans.  While few borrowers or their brokers have suffered drastic legal consequences from this practice (besides borrowers receiving loans they could not afford and facing foreclosure) a bankruptcy court recently denied a discharge for a borrower who was not truthful on her URLA.

Facts of the Case

In In re: Trimble, the borrower, Trimble, was a real estate professional who purchased a home.  As part of the purchase, Trimble completed a URLA where she stated that her monthly income was approximately 250% higher than it actually was.  In addition, she stated that she was planning on renting out another property she owned, which never happened.  Soon after receiving the loan Trimble defaulted.  The lender proceeded with the foreclosure and received a deficiency judgment against Trimble personally.  Trimble filed for bankruptcy protection in hopes of receiving a discharge, which would absolve her from any personal liability on her debt.


The court found that Trimble was not entitled to a discharge of the deficiency judgment because she had intentionally misstated her financial condition.  Under the bankruptcy statutes, while most debt is dischargeable, a debt can become nondischargeable if it was incurred through a fraudulent written statement about the debtor’s financial condition.  Here, there was no dispute that the URLA was a written statement about the borrower’s financial condition.  Further, the evidence demonstrated that the monthly income was false.  Finally, the Court found that the lender actually relied on the URLA to approve the loan and the reliance was reasonable because SISA loans were standard industry practice at the time.  Accordingly, since the lender was able to prove fraud, the deficiency judgment was deemed not dischargeable.


This decision was made by the Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of Mississippi.  Accordingly, it has no binding effect on California courts.  The key issue was a determination by the court that the lender’s reliance was reasonable.  The court found that because many lenders granted SISA loans, blind reliance on the URLA alone was reasonable.  However, it seems that other courts may find that SISA loans were, on their face, unreasonable or that the extremely high incomes reported by borrowers should have triggered a duty to investigate.  If either of these proves to be true, then a lender would likely not be able to prevent the discharge of the debt.

If you are a creditor dealing with a matter similar to the contents of this article and believe you need real estate legal representation, please contact Brewer Offord & Pedersen LLP at (650) 327-2900, or visit our website at

Latest Posts

Marijuana & Real Estate

Navigating the Unstable World of Real Estate and Cannabis in California

by Ashlee D. Gonzales, Esq. on June 25, 2018

Marijuana legalization in California is here, but the fact that the substance is still considered illegal at the Federal level is causing some confusion and hardships for growers and sellers. Learn about how to navigate the unknown areas in attorney [more]

Landlord & Tenant Law

5 Things Landlords Should Remember When Evicting Tenants

by Lorena Roel, Esq. on August 16, 2018

Summer is a time where most things slow down. School is out, vacations are plentiful, and the days are longer. What does not slow down is the housing market. With that inevitably comes evictions. A landlord who wants to regain [more]

Real Estate Contracts & Transactions

Selling Your Home with a Tenant Inside

by Ashlee D. Gonzales, Esq. on August 16, 2018

Being a landlord in California can be very rewarding, but also challenging at times. Being a landlord and trying to sell your home can be even more challenging. In the Bay Area specifically, we’ve noticed a slowdown in the market [more]